Small Business Advice

·

December 15, 2025

When Changing Payment Provider Doesn’t Make Sense (And When It Finally Does)

Nicholas Gould holding DOJO Payment Terminals
Nicholas Gould holding DOJO Payment Terminals

Most small businesses assume they should always be looking for a better deal. Cheaper rates, newer hardware, a different provider. But that mindset can lead to unnecessary changes that add complexity without delivering real value.

At Omnigo, there are times when the most honest advice we give is simple: you’re in a good place right now, and switching wouldn’t meaningfully improve anything.

This article explains why that’s sometimes the right call (and when it actually makes sense to revisit the conversation).

When your current setup is already working

In many cases, small businesses come to us having already achieved strong commercial terms. Their pricing is competitive, their setup works, and any potential saving from switching would be marginal.

In this situation, changing supplier often creates more disruption than benefit. New contracts, new hardware, new processes, and new learning curves, all for very little upside.

If your payments are reliable, your costs are under control and your day-to-day operation runs smoothly, there is no strong reason to move.

Why we don’t recommend change without a clear reason

We don’t suggest switching providers unless there are compelling reasons to do so. Those reasons are rarely about headline pricing alone.

A change only makes sense when something material shifts, for example:

  • Your transaction volumes increase significantly

  • Operational issues start affecting service

  • Reliability becomes critical during peak trading

  • Cashflow timing matters more as you scale

  • Your current provider can’t support how the business is evolving

Until one of those pressures appears, staying put is often the most sensible decision.

Pricing advantage can be marginal

One of the most misunderstood parts of payments is perceived savings. Businesses are often quoted slightly lower rates elsewhere, but when you factor in the effort, risk, and disruption of switching, the real advantage disappears.

If you’ve achieved competitive terms already, the incremental gain from changing supplier may be negligible. That’s why we’re upfront about it.

Right now, you may have achieved exceptional terms. The price advantage of moving is marginal. In that scenario, the correct advice is to pause, not push for change.

The right time to talk again

The conversation becomes valuable when the business changes.

When volumes grow, when systems are under strain, when reliability issues start costing you time or money, that’s the point where reviewing your setup makes sense. Not before.

At that stage, the focus shifts from “can I save a fraction of a percent” to “can my payments keep up with how I operate”.

Our approach

We’re not here to force switches. We’re here to make sure payment infrastructure supports the business properly, at the right stage.

Sometimes that means recommending a change. Other times, it means saying: stay exactly where you are, and let’s talk again when there’s a genuine reason.

That honesty is how long-term partnerships are built.

Start Where You Are. Scale With Us.

Trusted by 4,000+ UK businesses, from cafés to £1bn+ enterprises

Trusted by 4,000+ UK businesses, from cafés to £1bn+ enterprises

Small & Medium Businesses

Cafes, salons, retailers, venues, service-based businesses

Sage Coffee Shop Coventry

Small & Medium Businesses

Cafes, salons, retailers, venues, service-based businesses

Sage Coffee Shop Coventry

Enterprise

National chains, multi-site retailers, payment resellers, corporate partnerships

Enterprise London

Enterprise

National chains, multi-site retailers, payment resellers, corporate partnerships

Enterprise London

Built on the UK's Most Trusted Payments Infrastructure

1 in 8 UK high street transactions happen on a Dojo device. We’re proud to be one of their most trusted partners.

Unmatched Reliability

99.99% uptime, multi-cloud resilience, zero outages.

Faster Payments

Next-day payouts, even on bank holidays

Simple Setup

Remote onboarding, 4G fallback, no PCI headaches.

Award-winning Support

14-second average wait time to reach a real human.

“The tech is light-years ahead of what we used before, and the service is unreal.”

Chris O'Reilly

Mace Retailer

Request a Callback

Start saving money, streamlining operations, and unlocking growth without locking into a long contract.

Start saving money, streamlining operations, and unlocking growth without locking into a long contract.

Start saving money, streamlining operations, and unlocking growth without locking into a long contract.

info@omnigo.tech

0808 284 9096

Nicholas Gould

omnigo (reg trademark UK00003819960) is a trading name of Above Dynamics Ltd (registered in England 10831820) authorised payments consultants to Paymentsense Ltd since 2013. Acknowledgement is given to brands and logos used on this website, dojo our chosen partner is a trading name of Paymentsense Limited who are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA FRN 738728) and under the Electronic Money Regulations 2011 (FCA FRN 900925) for the issuing of electronic money and provision of payment services.

© 2025 — All rights reserved

omnigo (reg trademark UK00003819960) is a trading name of Above Dynamics Ltd (registered in England 10831820) authorised payments consultants to Paymentsense Ltd since 2013. Acknowledgement is given to brands and logos used on this website, dojo our chosen partner is a trading name of Paymentsense Limited who are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA FRN 738728) and under the Electronic Money Regulations 2011 (FCA FRN 900925) for the issuing of electronic money and provision of payment services.

© 2025 — All rights reserved

omnigo (reg trademark UK00003819960) is a trading name of Above Dynamics Ltd (registered in England 10831820) authorised payments consultants to Paymentsense Ltd since 2013. Acknowledgement is given to brands and logos used on this website, dojo our chosen partner is a trading name of Paymentsense Limited who are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA FRN 738728) and under the Electronic Money Regulations 2011 (FCA FRN 900925) for the issuing of electronic money and provision of payment services.

© 2025 — All rights reserved